Peer Review Policy
Peer Review Policy
1. Peer Review Principles and Policy
Tafkir: Interdisciplinary Journal of Islamic Education is committed to maintaining the quality, originality, academic rigor, and integrity of scholarly publications through a rigorous and impartial peer review process.
The journal applies peer review as an essential mechanism for evaluating the scholarly merit, methodological soundness, theoretical contribution, and relevance of submitted manuscripts to the fields of Islamic education and related interdisciplinary studies.
All manuscripts submitted to the journal undergo an initial editorial assessment to determine their alignment with the journal's focus and scope, compliance with submission requirements, originality, and overall academic suitability. Manuscripts that meet the initial requirements may proceed to external peer review by qualified scholars with relevant expertise.
The peer review process is designed to ensure that editorial decisions are based on academic quality, scholarly contribution, and research integrity rather than personal, institutional, geographical, or other non-academic considerations.
The journal expects all parties involved in the review process, including editors, reviewers, and authors, to uphold the principles of fairness, objectivity, confidentiality, transparency, and academic responsibility.
2. Reviewer Selection and Responsibilities
Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, research expertise, scholarly experience, and familiarity with the subject matter of the submitted manuscript.
Reviewers are expected to:
-
Evaluate manuscripts objectively, independently, and constructively.
-
Assess the originality, relevance, theoretical contribution, and methodological quality of the research.
-
Examine the clarity, consistency, and validity of research findings and interpretations.
-
Identify relevant literature and recommend additional references when academically necessary.
-
Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and all information obtained during the review process.
-
Disclose any potential conflicts of interest that may affect their impartiality.
-
Provide clear, evidence-based, and constructive recommendations to support the improvement of submitted manuscripts.
Reviewers must not use unpublished information or ideas obtained through the review process for personal or professional advantage.
3. Peer Review Process
The peer review process at Tafkir: Interdisciplinary Journal of Islamic Education consists of the following stages:
Stage 1. Manuscript Submission
Authors submit their manuscripts through the journal's online submission system and ensure that all required documents and submission information are provided in accordance with the journal's Author Guidelines.
Stage 2. Initial Editorial Screening
The editorial team examines submitted manuscripts to assess their relevance to the journal's focus and scope, compliance with author guidelines, originality, completeness, and general academic suitability.
Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's basic requirements or fall outside its scope may be returned to authors or rejected without proceeding to external peer review.
Stage 3. Reviewer Assignment
Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to qualified reviewers whose expertise corresponds to the subject and academic focus of the manuscript.
Stage 4. Peer Review Evaluation
Reviewers critically evaluate the manuscript's originality, theoretical foundation, research methodology, data analysis, findings, academic contribution, and overall presentation.
Reviewers provide written comments, suggestions, and recommendations to assist the editors in determining the manuscript's suitability for publication.
Stage 5. Editorial Decision
Based on the reviewers' reports and the editorial team's assessment, the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor makes the final editorial decision.
The possible decisions include:
-
Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication without further substantive revision.
-
Minor Revision: The manuscript requires limited revisions to address reviewers' comments.
-
Major Revision: The manuscript requires substantial improvements before it can be reconsidered for publication.
-
Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's academic or publication requirements.
Stage 6. Manuscript Revision
Authors receiving revision decisions are required to address the reviewers' and editors' comments carefully. Revised manuscripts should be accompanied by a response document explaining how each comment has been addressed.
The revised manuscript may be returned to the original reviewers for further evaluation when necessary.
Stage 7. Final Evaluation and Publication
Following satisfactory revision and editorial assessment, accepted manuscripts proceed to the subsequent stages of copyediting, proofreading, layout preparation, and publication.
Final publication decisions remain under the authority of the Editor-in-Chief.
4. Editorial Responsibilities and Decision-Making
The editorial team is responsible for ensuring that the peer review process is conducted fairly, consistently, and in accordance with the journal's publication ethics standards.
Editors must consider reviewers' recommendations carefully while retaining independent editorial judgment in making publication decisions.
Editorial decisions must be based on the manuscript's academic merit, relevance, originality, methodological quality, and contribution to scholarly knowledge.
Editors must also ensure that manuscripts are handled confidentially and that potential conflicts of interest are appropriately managed throughout the review process.
5. Confidentiality and Conflict of Interest
All manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents.
Reviewers and editors must not disclose manuscript content, unpublished findings, or review-related information to unauthorized parties.
Any actual or potential conflict of interest involving authors, reviewers, or editors must be disclosed to the editorial team. Individuals whose impartiality may be compromised should not participate in the relevant review or editorial decision.
6. Appeals and Review Integrity
Authors who wish to appeal an editorial decision may submit a written request to the editorial office, accompanied by clear academic arguments and relevant supporting evidence.
The editorial team will examine appeals objectively and may seek additional independent academic advice when necessary.
The journal is committed to maintaining the integrity of the peer review process and addressing concerns regarding reviewer conduct, editorial procedures, and potential violations of publication ethics.
7. Commitment to Academic Quality
Tafkir: Interdisciplinary Journal of Islamic Education considers peer review an essential component of responsible scholarly publishing.
Through a transparent, objective, and academically rigorous evaluation process, the journal seeks to promote high-quality research, encourage interdisciplinary dialogue, and contribute to the advancement of Islamic education and related fields of knowledge.
All participants in the publication process are expected to uphold the highest standards of academic integrity, professional responsibility, and ethical scholarly communication.
