Retraction Policy
Munaddhomah: Jurnal Manajemen Pendidikan Islam is committed to maintaining the integrity, transparency, and reliability of the scholarly record. The journal takes publication ethics seriously and follows established ethical principles in handling concerns regarding published articles.
A published article may be considered for retraction when there is clear evidence of serious violations of publication ethics or substantial problems that undermine the validity and reliability of its findings.
Grounds for Retraction
Retraction may be considered in cases including, but not limited to:
-
Plagiarism or substantial unattributed use of other authors' work.
-
Fabrication or falsification of research data.
-
Duplicate or redundant publication.
-
Serious errors that invalidate the research findings or conclusions.
-
Undisclosed conflicts of interest that have significantly affected the research or publication process.
-
Research conducted in violation of applicable ethical standards.
-
Manipulation of the peer review or publication process.
-
Other serious violations of publication ethics that compromise the integrity of the scholarly record.
Retraction Procedure
When an allegation or concern is raised, the editorial team will conduct an initial assessment to determine whether the matter requires further investigation.
The procedure may include:
-
Initial Assessment: The Editor-in-Chief or designated editor evaluates the allegation and available evidence.
-
Notification: The authors concerned are informed of the allegation and given an appropriate opportunity to respond.
-
Investigation: The editorial team examines the relevant evidence and may consult reviewers, editorial board members, institutional representatives, or other relevant parties when necessary.
-
Editorial Decision: Based on the findings, the Editor-in-Chief determines the appropriate action in accordance with publication ethics principles.
-
Publication of Retraction Notice: If retraction is warranted, a formal retraction notice will be published and linked to the original article.
Retraction Notice
A retraction notice will clearly identify the retracted article and explain the reason for the retraction. The notice will provide sufficient information to ensure transparency while respecting applicable legal and ethical considerations.
The original article will normally remain accessible in the journal's online archive, clearly marked as "Retracted", to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record. The retraction notice will be linked to the original article.
Corrections and Expressions of Concern
Not every concern requires retraction. Depending on the nature and seriousness of the issue, the journal may publish a correction or an expression of concern when appropriate.
A correction may be issued when an error does not invalidate the overall findings or conclusions of the article. An expression of concern may be published when an investigation is ongoing or when available evidence is insufficient to reach a final decision.
Editorial Independence and Fairness
All allegations will be handled objectively, confidentially, and fairly. Authors will be given an opportunity to respond to concerns, and editorial decisions will be based on evidence rather than personal or institutional interests.
Munaddhomah is committed to protecting the integrity of academic publishing and maintaining readers' trust in the scholarly record.
